The Second International Conference for
“Personal Epistemology and Learning (PEL)”
Abstract of Keynote Speech
Comparing Personal Epistemology of Science, Literature and Design
Ching Sing Chai
Nanyang Technological University, Singapore
The field of personal epistemology has been investigating individuals’ views about the nature of knowledge and the process of knowing both in a domain general manner and in subject specific context. Common factors surveyed under personal epistemology are certainty of knowledge (whether knowledge is certain or developmental) and the source of knowledge (whether knowledge are transmitted from authority or justify through personal or disciplinary ways of knowing) (see for example, Conley et al., 2004). To date, it seems that the domain general perspective has been gaining grounds (Wong & Chai, 2010) while the domain specific investigation has been focused on the investigation of the Nature of Science. This study is an initial attempt to survey individuals’ personal epistemology about how knowledge creation of Science, Literature and Design happens. It deviates from previous studies of personal epistemology and look into epistemology from knowledge creation perspective as knowledge creation is considered the most important competency for the knowledge age (Bereiter, 2002). Science, literature and design are considered as dealing with different realm of reality corresponding to Popper’s (1978) postulation of World 1 (the physical world), World 2 (the subjective world) and World 3 (the artificial world). Separate questionnaire were design for each of the discipline and undergraduate and postgraduate students’ epistemic beliefs about the ways the discipline create knowledge. The survey was validated and differences among students from different disciplines (science, engineering, design and literature) were compared. While the findings indicate students from different disciplines hold different understanding of how knowledge were created, the survey seems to require further fine tuning to be more sensitive to discipline differences.
Keynote Speaker
Prof. Ching Sing Chai (National Institute of Education, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore)
|